MENU GUIDES • 5 min read
Ordering the Same Thing Every Time
Written for the regular rather than the newcomer — and the fix is not to pick something new.
Defaults form because choosing is expensive and a bad order costs more than a slightly better one gains. The fix is to change one variable — the cheese, the protein, the cut, the side — rather than replacing the order. The biggest blind spots are the wraps, the gyoza and the rolled ice cream.
Everything else on this site is written for somebody deciding. This one is for somebody who stopped deciding a while ago — who orders the same thing every time, knows they do, and is quietly aware there are about a hundred and twenty items they have never tried.
That is not a failing. It is how ordering works, and there is a reason for it.
Why the same order wins
Choosing costs something. Faced with sixteen sections and a hundred and twenty items, the reliable option is worth more than the marginally better one, because the downside of a bad order is felt immediately and the upside of a slightly better one is not.
So the default hardens. It is usually the first thing you liked here, and once it exists it takes something specific to displace it.
Change one variable, not the order
The practical answer, and it is much easier than picking something new. Almost every item here has options attached, and changing one of them gives you a genuinely different meal without risking the whole order.
| If you always order | Change this | And you get |
|---|---|---|
| A Cheese Steak Philly | The cheese — provolone to Cheese Whiz | A noticeably different sandwich, same build |
| A Philly with steak | Chicken instead | Lighter, and the peppers and cheese come through |
| Bone-in wings | All flats, or a split across two sauces | The same order, better suited to you |
| A 12-inch anything | 7-inch plus a starter you have not had | The same amount of food, more of the menu |
| Fries, every time | Onion rings | The single highest-impact swap on the menu |
| The same sauce cup | Garlic sauce | Depth instead of heat, which most people have never tried |
The fries-to-rings swap is the one to start with. It costs nothing, it is a choice you are already making without thinking, and it changes a meal more than most people expect — the reasoning is in fries or onion rings.
The things regulars most often have not tried
Not the obscure items — the ones that sit in plain sight next to something more familiar:
- Gyoza — the only starter on the menu that is not battered or breaded
- The Garden or the Mushroom Steak — if you have only ever had the plain cheese steak
- Garlic fried shrimp — if you have had the plain and the buffalo
- A wrap — the lightest section, and the one people skip entirely
- Thai rolled ice cream — made on a cold plate in front of you, and the thing most regulars do not know is here
The wraps are the biggest blind spot. Five items, an entire section, and they eat completely differently from everything else on the menu — the five compared covers them.
Use the specials as a nudge
The weekday special list is the cheapest way to try something you would not otherwise order, because the risk is smaller: a side and a drink come with it, so even a miss is a complete meal.
Fifteen items on the all-day list, six at lunch, eight at weekends. If you have been ordering off the main menu out of habit, that list is the place to break it — and several of the items on it are things regulars have never tried. The guide to the three special menus sets out what is on each.
Ordering for two and want to try something new without risking your meal? Order your usual and one new thing to share, rather than swapping your order outright. You get the experiment and you still get dinner.
Order for the table, not for yourself
The most reliable way to see more of a menu is to stop treating your order as the unit. Two people ordering one dish each see two items; two people ordering one dish each plus one shared plate see three, and the third is where the experimenting happens.
It works because the shared plate carries no risk. If it is not for you, you still have your own order in front of you, and somebody else at the table will finish it.
- Two people — two mains and one starter you have never had
- Four people — two 12-inch sandwiches cut, in different builds
- Any number — one dessert to share, since most people never order it
- Never — four people all ordering the safe thing and nothing shared
When the habit is right
Worth saying plainly, because a piece like this can read as though variety is a virtue in itself. It is not. If the plain Cheese Steak with provolone is what you want, it is genuinely one of the best things here, and ordering it every time is a perfectly good strategy.
The case for changing is narrower than it sounds: try something new when you are ordering for a table anyway, when there is a special on that covers the risk, or when you are ordering something to share. The rest of the time, order what you like.
What to do on a day you are not adventurous
Most days, and there is nothing wrong with it. On those days the useful move is not to experiment at all but to make the order you already like slightly better: ask for the 12-inch cut in half if you are sharing, get the sauce on the side if it is travelling, add a cup you have not tried rather than a dish.
Those cost nothing, risk nothing and improve the meal you were going to have anyway. Everything else on this site is, in the end, a version of that.
The short version
Defaults form because choosing is expensive and a bad order costs more than a slightly better one gains. The fix is not to pick something new but to change one variable — the cheese, the protein, the cut, the side. And the biggest blind spots for regulars are the wraps, the gyoza and the rolled ice cream. Everything is on the full menu, and there is a guide to most of it.
A hundred and twenty items
Sixteen sections, and most people order from three of them.
Frequently asked questions
How do I try something new without risking my order?
Change one variable rather than the whole order — the cheese, chicken instead of steak, rings instead of fries, or a different sauce cup.
What is the easiest swap to make?
Fries to onion rings. It costs nothing, you are already making the choice, and it changes a meal more than people expect.
What do regulars most often miss?
The wraps, the gyoza and the Thai rolled ice cream — all in plain sight and all rarely ordered.
Are the specials a good way to try something?
Yes. A side and a drink come with them, so even an order you do not love is still a complete meal.
Is there anything wrong with ordering the same thing?
No. If it is what you want, it is a perfectly good strategy. Experiment when you are ordering for a table anyway.
More From the Kitchen
